Hello dear
Welcome To Nancy's Pizza
At Nancy's Pizza, we pride ourselves on delivering authentic Italian flavors with a casual twist. Nestled in vibrant Atlanta, our veteran-owned establishment specializes in Chicago-style deep-dish and thin-crust pizzas, perfect for a relaxed night out or a family gathering. We thrive on community, offering a warm environment that welcomes everyone, including pups! Expect a culinary journey filled with bold toppings, robust flavors, and a selection of vegan and vegetarian options. Our attentive staff ensures that every visit is memorable, whether you’re indulging in our signature pies or enjoying our happy hour specials. Join us for a slice of happiness!
About
Nancy's Pizza
Nancy's Pizza is a delightful destination for pizza aficionados nestled in the heart of Atlanta, GA. Located at 265 Ponce De Leon Ave, this veteran-owned establishment offers an array of Italian delights, primarily focusing on their signature pizzas. With a casual atmosphere that's perfect for families, groups, and even your furry friends, Nancy's Pizza ensures everyone feels welcome. The venue is not only spacious but also features a charming outdoor seating area, ideal for enjoying a meal in pleasant weather.
The menu here is a treasure trove for pizza lovers. Known for its Chicago deep-dish style, diners rave about the satisfying portions that often leave them coming back for more. Robert M. gushes, "Very satisfying. I ate more than I should have," which is a testament to the indulgent nature of their pizzas.
But pizza isn't the only highlight. The establishment also provides a variety of appetizers, including mozzarella sticks served with a generous helping of pesto and marinara sauces. While some guests have noted minor inconsistencies, such as the crunch of the cheese sticks, others emphasize the bold flavor adaptations that complement the experience beautifully.
Whether you're in the mood for a thin crust pizza or the classic deep dish, you'll find a range of toppings, including
- pepperoni
- jalapeños
- mushrooms
- Italian sausage
Beyond pizza, Nancy's offers plenty of additional amenities that enhance the dining experience. With options for vegan and vegetarian diets, a full bar, and even cryptocurrency payment acceptance, there's something for everyone. For those who enjoy a lively atmosphere, their happy hour specials and trivia nights add to the vibrancy of the venue.
Accessibility is also on their minds, with gender-neutral restrooms and options for catering. Plus, if you're a trivia buff or just want to enjoy a weekend evening out, this venue embraces a fun, communal spirit. The staff are incredibly attentive, ensuring your needs are looked after during your visit.
In conclusion, Nancy's Pizza delivers a robust experience that caters to various tastes and preferences. With its mix of hearty dishes and inviting environment, it's a spot where memories can be made over delicious food. Whether you're visiting for lunch or dinner, expect a satisfying dining experience that will keep you coming back.
Book a table
Make A Reservation
“ The pizza and wings were amazing! I loved the food my only concerned was them not wearing hair nets. That's why it's a 4/5 for me. ”
“ Chicago Deepdish! Very satisfying. I ate more then I should have, so good i couldn't stop. ”
“ Grading just the pizza and garlic cheese bread here. Not too bad. Thin crust, Midwestern style, so cut in squares. Toppings were great. Not a huge fan of the crust. Not sure exactly what it was about it. Not bad, the texture just seemed a little odd to me. Cheese bread was good. A little pricey, without the special they were running. ”
“ We walked over to Nancy's because it was incredibly close to our weekend place! They had a cute outdoor atmosphere, the weather was incredible and had we not walked and been a little hot, we may have sat out there! Indoor temperature was nice and cold and we were seated and greeted right away. We ordered the mozzarella sticks, which came with a pesto and marinara sauce. The sauces were phenomenal but, the sticks not so much. I wasn't really particular if the crumbs used to coat them. But the sauces def make us for it! So much spice and flavor. The 10" pizza was definitely enough for two people! We ordered the thin crust pepperoni and jalapeño. I will say the jalapeños did taste like jarred or canned jalapeños and not as much pepperoni flavor as I would be liked but overall the cheese pull and flavor was definitely good! Overall, the place, the service was great, - the gentleman that helped us was attentive and courteous! Def give this place a try! ”
“ I hadn't been to Nancy's in a LONG time since college, so when a friend suggested it for dinner, I was excited to go back to check it out. We were seated fairly quickly on a Thursday night, but didn't realize there was also trivia happening! I ended up ordering the slimmed, "lighter stuff" personal pizza and added on mushrooms, basil, and italian sausage. I also got a coke. The pizza took a while to come out which is understandable. The pizza was super delicious and I loved that the amount of cheese was lighter. However, the crust was really tough and incredibly hard to bite through. I did finish my pizza, but wish the crust had been a little bit chewier. Overall, there's definitely some other spots I like better for Detroit-style or other stuffed pizzas, but Nancy's is definitely a convenient option with a lot of space for groups. ”
“ This place was a nice surprise. We were seated promptly and had a great server who took care of us so well. We ordered a salad to share and it was good. The star was the pizza though. Baked perfectly. Amazing flavor. Not too doughy. I can say enough good about it. I like Chicago or Detroit pizza but even if you don't they have thin crust you could try As good as the pizza was the place was empty. Maybe they do a lot of take out? It was mid week. The restaurant was big with lots of room. Highly recommend ”
“ I visited on 3/24/2024 it's been a minute. Last time I went to Nancy's was at the Conyers location one time which is permanentlyclosed. I've been going to this location from time to time for years in midtown.I got a medium deep dish beef pizza this is a regular pizza that I enjoy. I purchased the bbq chicken pizza with bacon it has a hand tossed crust my bro and niece really enjoyed that pizza from the Conyers location when it was opened. The beef pizza is delicious. I only tried the medium I never ordered a small or large. ”
“ I was skeptical to order from here after reading some of the reviews but decided try anyway. Glad I did. I ordered through Uber eats since I'm visiting Atlanta. The pizza arrived hot and fresh. The presentation was amazing, I could not wait to dig in. I needed to cut the slices with a knife as the cheese had melted together. Omg. The taste was unmatched to any other pizza I've tasted. It was not greasy. The sauce has a great flavor. I couldn't really taste the pepperoni like I tasted the Italian beef, but it didn't matter because the pizza crust, cheese and sauce was so flavorful. I'm visiting for a weekend and I might order from here again. For 2 of us, the medium pizza and 7 count wings were just right. Hit the spot The wings were ok, nothing to write home about, ”
“ I got a couple things for takeout the other day and overall enjoyed the food! It's made relatively quickly and priced relatively reasonably. Almost everything was on point. The deep dish pizza was filled nicely and even tasted delicious on reheating. The fettuccine Alfredo was creamy and delicious, and I was able to add some toppings to it as well. The meatball trio app was well made. The only bad part was that the Brussel sprouts were truly G-d awful... as a huge fan of all things mustard (I dip my fries in yellow mustard, and honey mustard is my go-to salad dressing), and also all things Brussel sprout (seriously, if it's on the menu then 90% of the time I'll order it), you'll have to take my word for it, these were disgusting... try it if you must but don't say I didn't tell you so. Having said that I'll definitely be back! ”
